Lemon Ice Box Pie

Lemon Ice Box Pie

Lemon flavored anything is delicious. My favorite drink is lemonade. Lemon cake is an absolute necessity for my birthday every year. Then there’s Lemonheads! And who doesn’t love a lemon drop martini?

One of the first desserts I learned to make was Lemon Ice Box Pie. Mom had (or has is actually more likely) a glass pie plate that was red on the outside and white inside. It was the designated pie plate for this delicious summer time treat. As I got older, I decided it didn’t need to be hot outside to enjoy Lemon Ice Box Pie. At some point, my sister added cream cheese to the filling and it was even more tasty.

Mom’s original recipe called for a vanilla wafer crust. She used crushed vanilla wafers on the bottom and whole wafers around the edge. Mom topped her pie with a beautiful, silky meringue. I don’t eat the meringue but the pie feels naked and needy without it.

I’ve had to adjust the recipe a bit since I can’t have gluten. I use a pecan crust. Other than that the recipe has survived over the years and remains a family favorite. In case you plan to try it, please, please, please, use Eagle Brand condensed milk. I can’t be held responsible for the results if you try some other non-Eagle brand. @DariusCooks is usually correct, but this time, it does matter who squoze the lemon juice. Since lemon is the star of the show here, squeeze the juice yourself. Amen? Amen.

Y’all, check out Darius Williams all over SM and pick up a cookbook, too.




1 ½ cups of chopped pecans

1 Tbs oat flour

1 Tsp brown sugar

¼ cup of unsalted butter

Pie filling:

8 oz. package of cream cheese at room temperature (soft)

2 cans of Eagle Brand Sweetened Condensed milk (we all know that’s not evaporated milk, right?)

1 tsp. Vanilla paste or extract

½ tsp. Lemon extract

3 egg yolks, room temperature

⅔ cup of fresh squeezed lemon juice and zest from the lemons


6 egg whites (three from the yolks used earlier plus three more)

2 Tbs sugar

Preheat the oven to 350° F.

Add pecans, oat flour, brown sugar, and melted butter to a food processor. Use high speed to processor until the mixture is crumbly. Turn out into a pie plate and press crust along the bottom and up the sides of the pan. Bake for 8-10 minutes until toasted. The crust should appear dry. Allow to cool before filling.

Add the cream cheese to a large bowl or use a stand mixer. Beat the cream cheese for 3 minutes until light and fluffy. Add condensed milk to the cream cheese slowly, mixing constantly to allow the mixture to smooth out before continuing. After the first can is incorporated completely, the second can be added more quickly. Beat on medium speed until smooth. Add egg yolks one at a time. Mix in lemon zest and vanilla paste and beat for one minute. Filling should be smooth and silky. Stir or fold in the lemon juice. 

The lemon juice will cause the mixture to be soupy at first. It will thicken as the lemon juice “cooks” the eggs. Once the lemon juice is incorporated, pour the pie filling into the crust.

Prepare the meringue by beating the egg whites and sugar until soft peaks form. Add the meringue to the pie and bake for 15 minutes. The meringue should have lightly browned peaks. Allow pie to cool to room temperature and then chill in the “ice box” overnight or at least four hours.

Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s